Italian clinical audit - Centro Cardiologico Monzino di Milano
The Centro Cardiologico Monzino of Milano, Italy, has published its tenth consecutive annual clinical audit on surgical activity. The report included data on over 16,500 patients over a 12-year period (1997-2008) who underwent cardiac and vascular surgery at the Centre. The report concluded that the Centre had developed and maintained a high level of clinical audit and that its outcomes were in line with (and often better than) those of the most recent, regarded and reliable cardiac surgery databases and surveys, such as the STS Cardiac National Database (USA) and the National Adult Cardiac Surgical Database Report from the Society of Cardiothoracic Surgeons of Great Britain and Ireland.
However, historically, the Centre was not always able to produce rigorous clinical audit to such high standards. From 1997 to 2004, the Centre utilised a 'homemade' database based at first on Microsoft Superbase, then on Microsoft Access. According to Dr Stefano Salis, Consultant Cardiac Anaesthetist, and Clinical Audit Lead at the Centro Cardiologico Monzino, the statistical analyses the 'homemade' systems could perform were limited to mean ±standard deviation (or median). Although the homemade system could report single patient volume and outcomes, the hospital required a system that could provide:
Centro Cardiologico Monzino di Milano
- More advanced data analysis and reporting
- Outcome tracking and risk modelling
- Inbuilt risk stratification algorithms
- Logistic regression models
The overall aim of clinical audit is to improve patient outcomes by improving professional practice and the general quality of services delivered. The Centro Cardiologico Monzino tried to achieve this by reviewing patient care against agreed standards. Unfortunately, the homemade system utilised by the Centre restricted its ability to do so as the current system did not have a mechanism to perform advanced statistical analyses or implement a robust method for risk adjustment. The institution was eager to identify software that could be easily implemented into the Centre and which would allow a systematic and critical analysis of the quality of surgical activity provided.
Dr Salis, who had previously worked with Dendrite in 1999, when he worked as a cardiac anaesthetist at Bristol Royal Infirmary, UK, identified the company database as the preferred solution. The company had developed sophisticated software that had inbuilt risk stratification algorithms including Bayes and logistic regression models, allowing individual clinicians or institutions to benchmark their results against regional, national or international standards, adjusted for severity of illness using well-established statistical methods.
For the Centro Cardiologico Monzino, it was not only Dendrite's highly flexible software that supported multi-specialty applications that was appealing, it was also the company's expertise and extensive experience in planning and executing complex clinical database configurations for hospitals across Europe. Moreover, the company provided the hospital with several visits from their dedicated trainers for all those involved with inputting data, however simple or complex the level of data input required. In addition to site visits, the hospital was also provided with the necessary literature that outlined the different operational aspects of the Dendrite solution. Although there were some minor initial difficulties, these problems were easily solved through further cooperation between the company's technical team and the hospital's IT department.
The installation at the Centro Cardiologico Monzino di Milano, has dramatically improved the hospital's ability to perform a comprehensive clinical audit for cardiac and vascular surgery. According to Dr Salis, such audits are being considered more and more important at the hospital, and in the summer of 2008 the centre received accreditation by the European Cardiovascular and Thoracic Surgery Institute of Accreditation (ECTSIA).
The comprehensive, 100-page, 2008 report will document that the total peri-operative in-hospital mortality in 2008 was 2.85% for cardiac surgery and 1.1% for vascular surgery (cumulative cardiac and vascular 2.18%). Using the Logistic Euroscore as a risk-adjustment method the observed mortality was very much lower than the expected mortality in all risk classes. Furthermore, this latest report noted that the medium Logistic Euroscore for 2008 was 6.33, the highest in the last four years. The main post-operative complications were not cardiac related and were composed of renal insufficiency, respiratory insufficiency, neurological complications, intestinal ischaemia and necrosis. Interestingly, prior to the installation of the Dendrite system at the Hospital, data collection was only performed by anaesthetists.
|However, since its installation surgeons, perfusionists and anaesthetists input data onto the hospital's system - allowing data collection from the hospital's cardiac and vascular departments. This not only demonstrates the inherent flexibility of a system that can be utilised across different surgical departments, but also the system's ability to create an environment in which the analysis and reporting of data becomes easier and clinically meaningful, whatever the specialty.
"The software has significantly improved our ability to perform a comprehensive clinical audit for cardiac and vascular surgery. I think the software is a relatively complex one, and requires a considerable amount of time and commitment to fully use its potential," added Dr Salis. "However, the in-built capability of performing even complex analysis is a great help. Without this software I do not think we would be able to perform clinical audit in such a rigorous manner."
A copy of the 2008 report into surgical activity at the Centro Cardiologico Monzino di Milano, Italy is available at www.cardiologicomonzino.it